Skip to main content
Menu
Rooms Specials Event Calendar Gallery
(800) 972-6155Catalina Island Inn Phone BOOK YOUR STAYBOOK YOUR STAY
Catalina Island Inn Phone
Reviews

Reviews

Guests Say It Best

We've made it easy to find real feedback from real travelers like yourself. Check out the reviews below and start planning your visit to our Lincoln City hotel. After your stay, you can join the conversation and share your experience, too!

All Reviews

Sort by
Newest First
Oldest First
Lowest Rated
Highest Rated
Guest   •   February 01, 2026

Had a absolutely phenomenal ...

Had a absolutely phenomenal time. Clean rooms,hotub like bath and breathtaking view.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   January 30, 2026

We stayed two nights ...

We stayed two nights at Starfish Manor in a Nautica King room and had a great experience. The room was updated, very clean, and comfortable. The hotel is close to restaurants and offers direct beach access. Staff were friendly and helpful throughout our stay. The jacuzzi tub with a beach view was a standout feature and made the stay especially relaxing.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   January 23, 2026

Wonderful location. Great staff! ...

Wonderful location. Great staff! Ocean access is not far, great for unplugging to enjoy your trip.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   January 21, 2026

I know I went ...

I know I went off season but it was a beautiful view and a jacuzzi tub in room. Which was perfect after a long day of hiking on the foggy trails.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   January 21, 2026

Service was outstanding. ...

Service was outstanding. They explained everything when we checked in. The room was newly remodeled, clean and, very comfortable with fantastic views of the ocean. Would highly recommend.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   January 21, 2026

Needed a little vacation. ...

Needed a little vacation. I spent 3 nights in 201 and it is as very satisfying. The room has a balcony hot 🔥 tub with amazing views of the ocean 🌊. Kitchen is perfect and has two nice size bedrooms. One bathroom with nice shower. A quick walk to the beach ⛱️ Highly recommend.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   January 14, 2026

Love this place! The ...

Love this place! The Nautica Suite is the best! Great view. Beautiful room! Conscientious and friendly staff. This is our go-to place in Lincoln City.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   January 12, 2026

Hands down best place ...

Hands down best place to stay in Lincoln city, everything was perfect and I don't say that much! But wow also a place we stay now!
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   January 06, 2026

Service was excellent, and ...

Service was excellent, and friendly. There was a small issue with our room and staff fixed it right away for us. If I could give more stars for service, I would.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   January 03, 2026

Loved this hotel!! We ...

Loved this hotel!! We got a room with a tub in it and it was super relaxing. Great location, and great views.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
previous
next
 

Share your Experience

*
*
*
Share Your Rating *
*

Tell us more about your stay

Service
Quality
Cleanliness
By submitting this form, you consent to share the review along with your name on the site. We do not sell personal data to third parties. Your email address will not be made public but maybe used by us for communication purposes. If you are below 16 years of age, you are required to obtain prior permission from your legal guardian(s). If you wish to access or erase your personal information, you can do so by submitting your details here.
(800) 972-6155 BOOK YOUR STAY
  • Home
  • Our Hotel
  • Rooms
  • Specials
  • Local Area
  • Gallery