Skip to main content
Menu
Rooms Specials Event Calendar Gallery
(800) 972-6155Catalina Island Inn Phone BOOK YOUR STAYBOOK YOUR STAY
Catalina Island Inn Phone
Reviews

Reviews

Guests Say It Best

We've made it easy to find real feedback from real travelers like yourself. Check out the reviews below and start planning your visit to our Lincoln City hotel. After your stay, you can join the conversation and share your experience, too!

All Reviews

Sort by
Newest First
Oldest First
Lowest Rated
Highest Rated
Guest   •   March 21, 2026

Very nice hotel with ...

Very nice hotel with good accommodations. Clean room. Nice ocean view. Close to the beach. Bring a kite.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   March 20, 2026

I really enjoyed my ...

I really enjoyed my 2 night stay in the Nautica King room. The fireplace, balcony with chairs looking out to the ocean and the jacuzzi make it a great place. The only issue i ever have there is loud people up above me but thats not the hotels fault. Next time I will call ahead to request top floor. The new gym was a nice addition too! Highly recommend for a good priced, ocean front place.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   March 19, 2026

Rooms are a teeny ...

Rooms are a teeny bit dated but the view is beyond perfect. The sound of the surf permeates the room and those of us who grew up listening to that are transported back to our youth. Lots of places to eat nearby and so much more to see and do within a 20 minute drive. Oh, and right by a Casino.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   March 16, 2026

Beautiful ocean views from ...

Beautiful ocean views from the room with a hot tub! Very relaxing and romantic atmosphere.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   March 15, 2026

We had a lovely ...

We had a lovely stay at Starfish Manor. We made a mistake with our booking and the team at Starfish sorted it out with no fuss. Special shout out to Greg for his help and kindness. Definitely stay here if in the area.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   March 14, 2026

This was my second ...

This was my second time staying here, definitely not my last! I love it here. Both times I stayed in a Nautica suite room, on the 5th floor, and the views cannot be beat. Seeing and hearing the waves from almost the entire room, is my favorite. Watching the sunset from the jacuzzi tub is amazing. The staff is super friendly. I can't wait to come back!
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   March 13, 2026

This hotel is beautiful! ...

This hotel is beautiful! Quiet, Clean, Updated rooms and the jacuzzi tub in our room with an ocean view was wonderful. All of the staff were helpful and friendly, especially Gavin, who fixed a minor problem our first night of 3 quickly and professionally. Perfect getaway to unwind and relax while listening to and watching the waves right outside your door. Thank you for making our stay so enjoyable!
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   March 07, 2026

It's on the beach

It's on the beach
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   March 06, 2026

Our trip to starfish ...

Our trip to starfish manor was the perfect way to reset from our hectic daily routines! We got a room on the Lower level and were able to sit on the lawn chairs and watch the sunset! The hotel has close beach access and is close to food and shopping. Our room was spacious and big! The staff were friendly and very sweet! We will be coming back to stay again!
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   March 06, 2026

This was just what ...

This was just what I needed for a solo birthday retreat. Check-in was simple room was clean fresh and so cute. The jetted tub with a view omg so peaceful and beautiful. I had some online work I had to finish up great internet too! All the staff were friendly and helpful even the construction workers were kind not loud very considerate! Definitely will be back and highly recommend it.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
previous
next
 

Share your Experience

*
*
*
Share Your Rating *
*

Tell us more about your stay

Service
Quality
Cleanliness
By submitting this form, you consent to share the review along with your name on the site. We do not sell personal data to third parties. Your email address will not be made public but maybe used by us for communication purposes. If you are below 16 years of age, you are required to obtain prior permission from your legal guardian(s). If you wish to access or erase your personal information, you can do so by submitting your details here.
(800) 972-6155 BOOK YOUR STAY
  • Home
  • Our Hotel
  • Rooms
  • Specials
  • Local Area
  • Gallery