Skip to main content
Menu
Rooms Specials Event Calendar Gallery
(800) 972-6155Catalina Island Inn Phone BOOK YOUR STAYBOOK YOUR STAY
Catalina Island Inn Phone
Reviews

Reviews

Guests Say It Best

We've made it easy to find real feedback from real travelers like yourself. Check out the reviews below and start planning your visit to our Lincoln City hotel. After your stay, you can join the conversation and share your experience, too!

All Reviews

Sort by
Newest First
Oldest First
Lowest Rated
Highest Rated
Guest   •   May 26, 2025

My Wife and I ...

My Wife and I Are Back At this Wonderful Place 💗 It's Now Our 7th Anniversary we have spent Here. Just got here. Always a wonderful Staff and Peaceful as well as calming!! 5 Stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   May 18, 2025

Absolutely amazing experience at ...

Absolutely amazing experience at Starfish! This was our first time visiting the hotel and 5 stars across the board. From the rooms to the employees-everything was wonderful. We will back!
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   May 14, 2025

Nice rooms and quiet

Nice rooms and quiet
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   May 10, 2025

Staff is very attentive, ...

Staff is very attentive, we stay here quite often, service is top-notch, room was amazing, romantic. We look forward to our next stay. We love this place. Love love love the jacquizzi in the room instead of outside. Mr and Mrs Brent Noon Salem, Oregon
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   May 06, 2025

Really Really Lovely Hotel. ...

Really Really Lovely Hotel. Newly Renovated Rooms,( I am imagining because everything is so fresh) , Great Location, Decor/ Colors, and Fabulous Jet Tub With The View! Such A Great Find! Great Lobby as well. Cute space for a bar located on second level...let's open it! Love it!
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   May 01, 2025

Love this place !

Love this place !
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   April 28, 2025

Starfish Manor is the ...

Starfish Manor is the best establishment I have ever stayed at. You have great customer service, fine decor, awesome cleaning service, beautiful scenery, and the hot tub is everything. Big shout out to joy, her cleaning skills are outstanding. Thank you joy. It is the best place to stay.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   April 11, 2025

Really nice, stay here ...

Really nice, stay here for a night , and it was nice they had two shower heads. In the shower 🚿 that was a plus. 👍 clean room with a nice view, only the downside was beach access, was a lot of climbing, and that there was no breakfast. For the price. The in room hot tub is really nice to .
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   April 09, 2025

This room was excellent ...

This room was excellent priced. It was clean and the staff was friendly.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
Guest   •   April 06, 2025

My wife and I ...

My wife and I stayed here for a few days and we absolutely loved this place and will be returning. The staff was friendly and helpful and the view and rooms were amazing.
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
previous
next
 

Share your Experience

*
*
*
Share Your Rating *
*

Tell us more about your stay

Service
Quality
Cleanliness
By submitting this form, you consent to share the review along with your name on the site. We do not sell personal data to third parties. Your email address will not be made public but maybe used by us for communication purposes. If you are below 16 years of age, you are required to obtain prior permission from your legal guardian(s). If you wish to access or erase your personal information, you can do so by submitting your details here.
(800) 972-6155 BOOK YOUR STAY
  • Home
  • Our Hotel
  • Rooms
  • Specials
  • Local Area
  • Gallery